David Vance SubstackRead More
Can we start by accepting that Islam isn’t a race? Muslims aren’t a race either. Islam is an ideology—it is a set of beliefs and rules that shapes how its followers view the world. And like any ideology, from communism to capitalism, it should be open to criticism. No free pass But this is where things get tricky: Islam doesn’t take kindly to critique. And that’s an understatement! The body count tells a different story.
Unlike other ideologies that might just ignore or debate their detractors, Islam has a track record of answering questions with violence. Criticise it, and you risk more than a heated argument. Apostasy? That’s considered a death sentence in many Islamic texts and countries. The world, according to Islam’s core tenets, is split starkly: believers and the subjugated. No middle ground. I don’t think any Islamic scholar would dispute this and yet if we say it this is considered unacceptable.
Why? Because questioning Islam gets you labeled by our media as a bigot, even though you’re critiquing ideas, not skin colour. Islam isn’t just a religion. It’s a political system with totalitarian roots, cloaked in spiritual garb. And our media plays defence for it.
History is clear – look at the caliphates, the conquests, the legal codes that governed every facet of life, from speech to dress to punishment. This isn’t about Muslims as individual people. It’s about an ideology that demands submission and punishes dissent. If we can question democracy, socialism, or any other system, we can question Islam. Anything less is intellectual cowardice.
When Grok AI went “mental” a few days ago, I asked it a simple question. See the answer for yourself!
I agree with Grok. However 24 hours later, Grok disagreed with itself
Looks like even AI is scared to challenge Islam!
*** If you enjoy my work here, can I ask you to consider becoming a PAID subscriber, it’s only £5 a month, you can cancel if you don’t enjoy it but I know you will. I want to thank the kind people who already do this, without your help this becomes impossible. Thank you in anticipation of your support***
