David Vance SubstackRead More
The Irish State wants to monitor your WhatsApp messages, Naturally this is all being wrapped up in the rhetoric of “fighting crime” but the totalitarian impulse in play here is intense!
The Irish government is advancing legislation to expand the surveillance powers of An Garda Síochána, Ireland’s police service, allowing them to intercept and monitor live conversations on private messaging apps like WhatsApp, iMessage, and Instagram.
The proposed scheme will grant the Irish Police the ability to access encrypted communications in real time, provided they obtain judicial approval for specific operations. Knowing how compliant the Irish judiciary is, getting approval should pose few problems!
This snooping law is being sold on the basis that it will address serious crimes, such as organised crime and terrorism, by enabling law enforcement to keep pace with technological advancements used by criminals. But who actually believes that?
It represents a dangerous overreach by the Irish State, infringing the fundamental right to privacy for ordinary Irish citizens. It’s also what I would expect from the mendacious Irish political establishment who desperately want to snoop of everyone! They hate the idea that we can talk and they are locked out of our private conversations!
On a positive note, the legislation’s implementation is less clear. How will the big tech companies like Meta, Apple, and Google respond, given the end-to-end encryption that protects these platforms? Will they meekly comply with requests to provide access or will they recognise that if technical workarounds, such as backdoors, are granted, this will weaken encryption security?
The Irish Data Protection Commission which is a key regulator for tech companies in the EU, has remained strangely silent on the proposal’s compliance with GDPR or other privacy laws. Tech platforms may well resist, potentially leading to legal battles, as seen in past Irish privacy disputes.
However it is telling that the Irish Government sees your messaging privacy as something that need to be compromised so it can see what you are saying in real time.
*** If you enjoy my work here, can I ask you to consider becoming a PAID subscriber, it’s only £5 a month, you can cancel if you don’t enjoy it but I know you will. I want to thank the kind people who already do this, without your help this becomes impossible. Thank you in anticipation of your support***
